Categories
New Series

Dark Water: Don’t Fuck This Up

capaldi gomez

Buck up, and give me some attitude

All season I have cried out for this. Do something different. Change the record. Rewrite the rules. And I don’t mean create female Doctor. That’s the most boring thing you could do, in desperate search of something interesting. Do something new: don’t bring someone back to life; don’t have love save the day; don’t rely on a tired revelation.

I’ll overlook the female Master thing because, frankly, that isn’t very interesting. In fact it’s the most obvious thing you could have done. Do something people didn’t expect and can’t figure out. Do The Power of the Daleks; Spearhead From Space; Genesis of the Daleks; City of Death; Warrior’s Gate; Enlightenment; Revelation of the Daleks; The Happiness Patrol; Ghost Light; The End of the World; Waters of Mars; The Eleventh Hour; Deep Breath. The New Adventures.

Something different.

Right now, I don’t know what’s going on. Neither does the Doctor; neither does Clara. That’s how I want things to stay. I don’t want a reset button that sets up a cosy Christmas special. I want ramifications; causality. I want this to mean something. No death cheats. No bait-and-switch. No tricksiness. None of that Sherlock bullshit. Dark Water has to be the moment that everything changes. A break from RTD and Moffat when people die and come back to life, the universe is rebooted, the baddies consigned to some ethereal netherworld that didn’t previously exist.

Don’t cheat me. Don’t lie to me.

In the same way that Clara is frustrated with the Doctor, I’m frustrated with the Doctor. He has lied to me again and again – and tried to pass it off with a cheeky line, a self-reflexive remark.

Dark Water has promised me all of these things. A great Doctor in Capaldi. An intriguing set-up in Heaven and Hell. Cybermen. The Master. Death and the lack of it. Frankly, I’m not sure whether this is suitable for Doctor Who’s viewership, but I asked for it, so I can’t complain that I’m getting it.


An interlude. Here are the things that are boring, predictable and crap about Dark Water:

• Missy being The Master. This was the least interesting and most predictable of the ‘who is Missy?’ options.

• Missy kissing the Doctor and being flirtatious. Like every Timelord thing since the reboot. To not have a Timelord behave in this manner would frankly be much more interesting.

• The Cybermen. They haven’t been any good since The Tenth Planet. 48 years ago. Nothing about Dark Water thus far suggests that will change.

• The Cybermen stomping around. This has never been good and the prospect of the Cybermen stepping noiselessly from their tanks is the most interesting thing Moffat could have done with them. Not recognising that is frankly embarrassing.

• Murray Gold’s Cyberman leitmotif. Appalling for fully eight years. Using it here is as insane as using Space Adventure from Tomb of the Cybermen in Revenge of the Cybermen or the Dudley Simpson’s wobbly synthesiser Master motif in Keeper of Traken. Stop it, for God’s sake. Boring, unimaginative, idiotic and not any good whatsoever.

• I suspect Moffat is buying time on the ‘female Doctor’ debate with this move. I find it instructive that Moffat is making all the right noises on this without actually doing anything about it. And the fact that we now have Capaldi as a Doctor and a definite shift in the character’s, well, character without the series changing one whit suggests to me that changing the Doctor’s gender would be as meaningless in terms of what it did for the series as I always suspected. I’ve seen RTD putting a tick next to the female Doctor thing recently. Again, I’d note that not only did he not do it, he dismissed the idea when he was in charge. The actions of both showrunners indicate that they can’t square the idea themselves but don’t have the courage to elucidate why. My suggestion is that they recognise as a fundamentally naff idea; not only is it superficially popular but it’s an idea that’s been around for decades. Doctor Who needs a tonal shift, not a reskin.

• Danny Pink. I still don’t care. And if he comes back to life – regardless of what is explained in this episode – it’s an automatic five points off in whatever mark I give it on Gallifrey Base.


Virtually every series of Doctor Who has promised change in this way since it returned. It’s OK Corral time; the series’ very own Trenzalore. It cannot bear any more dishonesty. If this is where we’re going, this is where we’re going.

Moffat has dangled the biggest bait we’ve ever seen in Doctor Who. And I’m not sure I like the direction it appears to be going. But it’s too late to have regrets. A bold new future, an afterlife, a path we’d never considered has been opened up. It’s frightening, new, possibly inappropriate.

But it’s new. And new is what Doctor Who needs. Seize the day, Steven.

Categories
New Series

The Caretaker: People Being Horrible To One Another

It was OK. I liked the Skovox Blitzer – genuinely great name – and at least it didn’t get packed off with its mate and zoom off into the sunset. Chris Addison was good. The stuff with the young girl nicely raised two fingers to the appalling squits of Neil Gaiman’s episode. I could go on about how astonishingly derivative this series of Doctor Who is – how The Caretaker was a straight-down-the-middle retread of School Reunion and The Lodger – but I’d be getting as repetitive as Season 8.

There was a recurring motif in The Caretaker and it was people being horrible to one another. The Doctor makes constant disparaging remarks about Clara’s appearance that are sometimes funny and frequently not, so it’s not without precedent this season. Elsewhere the Doctor refused to believe that Danny Pink was a maths teacher because – as a soldier – he clearly can’t have much up top (forgetting that his bestest mate ever was a soldier, apparently).

Doctor-Who-The-Caretaker

There’s another incorrect but not-wholly-unreasonable reading of why the Doctor goes out of his way to insult Danny’s intelligence and preferred the unthreatening wavy-haired white guy – it’s not so unreasonable as the Doctor’s sudden and unexplained hatred of soldiers just comes from nowhere really. For his part Danny immediately locates an open wound – the Doctor’s self-doubt and even self-loathing over his own character – and sticks a fork into it, goading the Doctor as an authoritarian control freak. It’s hardly The Trout, Jamie and Victoria.

Throwing a traumatised soldier with emotional problems into a school environment is one thing, hoying him into the TARDIS crew might seem a little edgy but putting Danny Pink into a day-glo strawberry milkshake adventure such as The Caretaker seems rather jarring. That Pink – a trained soldier who is clearly intelligent, troubled and intense – should start burbling Mickey-and-Rory-esque stuff about Space Dads spelt it out in case no-one had spotted it earlier. That he defeats the universe’s most efficient killing machine by performing a 20-foot Mighty Morphin Power Ranger somersault over its head is similarly problematic. But there’s something even more problematic about Danny Pink.

Danny Pink strikes me as the kind of character who might tell Clara to wipe a particularly garish shade of lipstick off her face; encourage her to give up her job so she can stay at home and look after the kids; issue ultimatums to our heroine if she does not obey his commands. Actually, come to think of it, that’s exactly what he did in this episode in the latter case – already this feels like a troubling power dynamic. Throw him into an episode of Cracker as a spousal abuser and you wouldn’t have to change a stroke: a brooding, frowning, jealous control-freak with PTSD who gets handy with his fists from time-to-time only because he loves his missus so much.

Doctor-Who-The-Caretaker-Danny

I’ve little truck with the squadrons of lunatics who bay for Moffat’s blood or would accuse him of being an unreconstructed bigot, but there is a case to be answered as far his writing of female characters is concerned. Tonight’s episode had a good example where Clara – The Impossible Girl – mutely acceded to Danny’s demand that he tell her the truth (his repeatedly growling that he doesn’t like being lied to is similarly uncomfortable) or they were done as a couple.

Moffat’s Doctor Who has a habit of setting up strong, independent women who lose all their agency – and frequently knickers – when The Doctor turns up. In this case it’s Danny Pink who causes Clara to go all gooey. When strong female characters get all hot and bothered about the Doctor I don’t mind too much: the whole set-up of the show (in the last nine years anyway) is that he’s so remarkable anyone would follow him around the galaxy. But in that instant when Clara nuzzled into Danny’s chest she just melts away as the character we’ve known.

Moffat’s clumsiness at writing women, incidentally, is one of the one of the reasons why I was so against a female Doctor. But six episodes into the series I’m not sure Moffat is that great at writing for the Twelfth Doctor. This is odd, as Peter Capaldi is a middle-aged Scot with a love of Doctor Who. Sound familiar?

I started to question this while watching Time Heist last week. Just what is the Twelfth Doctor? He seems, in his worst moments, like an amalgam of the Tenth and Eleventh Doctors – the NuWho archetypes – in a bad mood. Capaldi seems to be bringing everything there is to the character at the moment, with little clue as to what this new incarnation is all about from the scripts, bar Deep Breath.

The series opener feels like an ever-more-distant memory a month on. It has been the only episode – halfway through the series – that felt like a confident statement about what makes this Doctor and this season tick (no pun intended) and what makes them different. Ever since it’s felt like the show has been folding in on itself: rehashing old storylines, old monsters, old writers. The show, understandably and inexplicably at the same time, feels old.

Is this what Moffat, Gareth Roberts and Peter Capaldi would have dreamed of when they imagined the chance to create new Doctor Who? For what it’s worth I expected far more riffing on the title of this week’s episode, but it doesn’t feel as if Moffat does care that much – what else can possibly explain the run of desperately unambitious retreads of former glories this season?

Yes, Clara and the Doctor look after one another; yes Danny wants to look after Clara and, yes, the Doctor looks after the planet. He’s the celestial caretaker. Everyone cares. Alas, increasingly, I don’t.

Hush child stop addlepating me!

Sign up here for more of this frack

Powered by WordPress Popup