Categories
New Series

Caves and Twins: Hide

I liked Hide. Like last week’s Cold War, it wore its influences on its sleeve but, unlike Gatiss’ effort, I thought it added to them and was more satisfying.

Another similarity to last week was an elevated level of fear and threat. Only on very rare occasions – usually in Moffat’s early episodes – has Doctor Who been scary in its new iteration. Off the top of my head I’d nominate The Empty Child, The Girl In The Fireplace, Blink, Midnight and The Time Of Angels as really trying to be unsettling.

There have been many CGI monsters in the new series, shot unimaginatively and looking never less than convincing while, of late, Doctor Who hasn’t really seemed to try very hard to be scary – or has seemed to deliberately undercut any drama or uncanny with Matt Smith waltzing around being a dork.

doctor-who-series-7-hide-promo-pics-4

I’m not sure if this has actually been deliberate or not, but the outcome has been much the same. Doctor Who has never less seemed less in touch with that old behind-the-sofa chestnut since Season 24, when it was barely in touch with its senses, nevermind anything else.

In Hide there was a definite attempt to shit the kids up in a couple of different ways. First off the ghost – a clear red herring and quite obviously a riff on The Stone Tape. I say ‘riff’, what I mean is ‘direct lift’. But all that haunted-house mise en scene was pleasant enough and played with conviction by Jessica Raine and Dougray Scott.

But there was something else lurking in the house, shot in a jerky stop-motion kind of style that reminded me of the Silent Hill and Resident Evil series of video games, with their twitching horrors. The pocket universe side-step was interesting, creepy and extremely good-looking – the sense of threat ramped up and a creeping horror emerging.

It was a bit disappointing that the TARDIS came to the Doctor’s rescue, despite the cuteness of the TARDIS sniping at Clara. But really that resolution was as weak as the TARDIS switching off the plot in The Parting Of The Ways – and the time-travelling side-steps felt exactly like what it actually was; padding.

The coda to it all was, inevitably, that love saved the day – with the two women’s blood ties enabling the link and the two creatures merely wanting to entwine their twisted forms around one another. I’m quite ambivalent about this, as the series seems to be doing this to death. On the other hand I liked the fact that the two monsters were genuinely hideous, voiceless and – largely – not CGI. It harked back to an old trope of the series, that horrible creatures weren’t necessarily horrible.

Doctor Who … Dougray Scott and Matt Smith in Hide.

However, it was another run-out for another Moffat stand-by, namely an apparently-straightforward story performing a 90-degree turn at the end, subverting the initial narrative. The Curse of the Black Spot – a tiresome pirate runaround – became an incoherent mess when it detoured into Michael Crichton territory at the end and became about a malfunctioning robot nurse, or something. Similarly the promising God Complex went from a surreal nightmare-in-every-room pysch-out to a dreary comment on the nature of Gods.

In the first case it at least turned the most predictable television in some decades into something marginally more interesting; in the latter case it almost ruined an enjoyable story. In Hide the pocket universe swerve injected some life into a familiar tale; in the case of the latter revelation it felt like much of Moffat’s proselytizing – the sort that only be written by a sentimental middle-aged man with a young family, dribbling at the wonder of it all.

No doubt I’m saying this because I’m a ming-mong, but I can’t empathise with this ‘love is a many-splendoured thing’ mode of storytelling; not because I can’t appreciate what a wonderful emotion it is, but because I don’t buy it. It’s corny, phony and smacks more of trying to paper over the cracks in the plot than anything earnest.

I’ll give Hide a pass on that score, because it was a superior pastiche and because the plot-swerve added something to the overall story. With Clara’s identity just-about retaining the interest, JLC’s strong performance and two excellent guest stars – particularly Raine – Hide represents the most successful of Season 7’s episodes thus far. The characterisation of the Eleventh Doctor continues its slide into Tennant-style self-parody however; let’s hope someone notices soon and sets Matt Smith back on the right track.

Categories
New Series

Caves and Twins: The Bells of St Trinians

Doctor_Who__Steven_Moffat_s_episode_guide___The_Bells_of_Saint_John

It was called something like that, wasn’t it? I can’t be bothered to look it up I’m afraid. Was the world really crying out for a pastiche of an RTD season opener? A modern-day invasion-y thing, some London landmarks, a shouty Doctor who can’t be heard over the terrible music during action scenes, a smart-arse “sassy” female companion and some technology references. It was only a surprise that Trinity Fucking Wells wasn’t in it.

Caves

– I liked seeing The Great Intelligence as the baddie. Was this a modern-day Web of Fear? A London Invasion, the Intelligence, the, er, web? Only not very good, obviously.

– I still, just about, like Clara. But if she’s going to turn into another wisecracking, eyebrows-raised, lip-licking, down-boy Moffat Female Character that won’t last much longer.

– I quite enjoy Matt Smith. But I wish his Doctor could be turned down a bit.

Twins

Hard to divorce any elements from the whole, really. But it was so lacking in ambition, so workmanlike that you could imagine boxes being ticked – a crashing plane, a flying motorbike racing through London, the Shard, the internet. Whispers of Moffatt’s writer’s block, lack of energy, his divided time, his dodgy priorities and diminishing interest in the series seem validated by such lacklustre stuff as Bells of St Wotsits.

Clara. We’re clearly supposed to be on the edge of our seats about who Clara is. I’m not. I’m not really bothered. I think this Companion Arc template is past its sell-by-date, frankly. Jenna-Louise Coleman is playing the part well, but I’m not convinced she’s very interesting – and this fractured identity macguffin isn’t working for me.

Murray Gold’s music. It seemed to me that Gold was a lot better of late. But the guy cannot score action scenes. He simply can’t do it. All of his music when there’s fighting, running, driving or battle is laughably bad. The score during the scene tonight when the Doctor and Clara were biking to the Shard was so terrible I almost turned off the television.

• Overall, forgettable. Though not actually as bad as any of RTD’s season openers, this one had all of the ingredients. It was like seeing Horns of Nimon during Season 26. We keep hearing about how Doctor Who needs to move on from the past but watching the Bells of St Thingy – and knowing that Tennant and Piper are coming back – it seemed like someone had turned back the clock. I suppose that having a time machine makes such things academic.

Hush child stop addlepating me!

Sign up here for more of this frack

Powered by WordPress Popup