Categories
New Series

Caves and Twins: The Idiot’s Lantern

I think this episode may be the most forgettable of the modern Doctor Who. Certainly not worst, in fact it isn’t really bad, but one that barely dented my conciousness at the time.

Indeed, I’ve frequently been unable to recall the actual tite. The Empty Faces? The Hungry Televisions? In actuality The Idiot’s Lantern is a great title.

And all of the parts are impressive but I don’t think they gel – and the pacing is very leisurely for the first two thirds (and benefits as a result) but then everything is resolved in a flash, leaving the valedictory ‘gay son gains self-esteem’ epilogue.

It’s less than the sum, but it’s better than Gatiss’ next two efforts. After The Unquiet Dead it seems not unreasonable to ask what went wrong.

Caves

Some excellent little flourishes from Euros Lyn, using unusual angles and close-ups to good effect.

The encounters with faceless people are all spooky and odd.

The conceit of the Wire is quite nice and sometimes well-realised

I quite like all the 50s nonsense that the Doctor and Rose do and their interactions feel rather more Whoish here, rather than the horrid mutual admiration codependence displayed elsewhere in series two.

All the performances are good, even if Maureen Lipman overdoes it somewhat.

The BBC shows how well it can do period dressing and ambiance again.

Twins

I can’t make head nor tail of the way the plot is resolved. Admittedly I wasn’t glued to the set while it was on, but the Doctor pushes some buttons and something happens and everything is OK? (See also: Daleks In Manhattan).

The whole abusive father / gay son subplot never feels anything less than awkward.

Tennant being angry. I remember reading with disbelief that Ian Briggs thought Sylvester McCoy played ‘angry’ very well. I wonder if the same thought occurred to virtually everyone who wrote for Tennant. They’re about as right as Briggs was.

Categories
Classic Series

RIP Mary Tamm

The recent explosion of Big Finish audios, mining classic series companions, monsters, guest charatcers and actors had shown us one thing recently: the Doctor Who universe had an embarrassment of riches to call on in the time of the series revival and new ascendancy.

And, without putting too fine a (morbid) point on it, much of the classic Doctor Who universe was still with us until the last couple of years. We had lost Jacqueline Hill and Ian Marter tragically young, while Mike Craze departed in the late 90s. But of the former Who companions all were still going strong, popping up in spin-offs, audios and conventions here and there.

The last 18 months has been a sad time to be a Doctor Who fan though. Nick Courtney, Lis Sladen, Carry John and now Mary Tamm have passed away. Nick’s loss, as a kind of spiritual leader of the Doctor Who family, was felt keenly but the passing of the three lady companions was shocking and seemed unfair.

They were not old, by today’s standards, and we did not know of their illnesses – so learning off their loss has, for me, been tinged with a kind of disbelief. I reacted to the news of Sladen, John and Tamm dying with a kind of instinctive noise of dismay.

We clearly experience the deaths of Who alumni with sadness – and I always find myself asking myself why. Clearly that connection to childhood nostalgia is part of it – a reminder of the passing of time and the gentle melancholy that is inspires. But I think, beyond that, is a fundamental fondness for the people who made our show what it was. More than other TV personalities we might recognise from our youths; more so, possibly, than people in the public eye to whom we should pay more respect: public servants, charity workers, good eggs.

Perhaps that’s what it is to be a fan. A sense of ourselves as part of a big family, no matter how slightly, how much we may disavow it and how much we’ve found ourselves drift away from a programme. Our big, dysfunctional, ramshackle Doctor Who family is diminished a little – and somehow we feel that loss more than we’d expect to, if only for a second.

I met a couple of Who companions, but never Mary Tamm – someone I always thought was the most beautiful Who companion among dozens of beautiful women.

I’m not going to attempt a retrospective of her career or assessment of her role as Romana I. But I do mourn her passing, as I expect will the rest of fandom for the same reasons. RIP Mary.

Read this interview for Mary’s take on her time in Doctor Who or this one for a nice interview retrospective. Here’s a nice outtake from back in the day.

Hush child stop addlepating me!

Sign up here for more of this frack

Powered by WordPress Popup