Categories
General TV stuff

The Trap: What Happened To our Dream of Freedom?

First printed in The Courier, Newcastle’s student newspaper, in 2007

The suggestion that humanity’s increasingly widespread conception of itself as inherently untrustworthy and deceptive in terms of inter-personal relations creates a knock-on effect on national and international relations is scarcely a new idea, but rarely has it been examined with such verve as in BBC2’s The Trap: What Happened To our Dream of Freedom.

This three part documentary is presented by Adam Curtis, the same auteurish filmmaker who wrote and directed the similarly excellent The Power Of Nightmares in 2004.

The central conceit, briefly and superficially, is that domestic and international policy is still directed by the same ideology that regulated Cold War policy, ‘game theory’, which is based on the assumption that humanity is fundamentally a selfish, duplicitous race who will back-stab each other wherever possible, and therefore the only solution is a mutual disincentive in all parties to initiate aggressive action towards one-another, such as a huge arsenal of nuclear weapons.

Hand-in-hand with this insular ideology has sprung, paradoxically, an increased valuation of personal freedom, which will, Curtis argues, ultimately disintegrate under the immense weight of Game Theory ideology.

Phew. Conceptually, little of this is new; the brilliance of The Trap lies in the fact that it’s essentially an immensely powerful mood piece, filled with terrifying bleak imagery and wonderfully grim music. It’s also intelligent theorizing for a mass-audience. In short, you should watch it.

• As if to confirm the allegations made in The Trap, Channel 4’s Dispatches (Mondays, 8pm) program conspires to prove to us that even our beloved Prince of Wales is an utter bastard.

It’s not very interesting, but there’re some truly funny comments made towards the end, particularly when the various talking heads are discussing Charles’s ‘alleged’ overindulgence. For instance, some posh woman mentions with disgust the ‘tremendous arrangements’ associated with Charles’s banqueting and shin-digs.

Then there’s a fat bespeckled bloke from The Independent who talks with distaste about the fact that Charles ‘swims with slightly fetid international billionaires’. To cop it all off, the presenter, Simon Barnes, starts most of his sentences with the phrase ‘despite accusations of extravagance…’

Perhaps I’m being obtuse. Isn’t suggesting that the Royal Family’s most profligate member may be extravagant simply to state the obvious? Is it not along the same lines as averring that Stalin may have had fascistic leanings buried beneath the façade?

Perhaps not, and just maybe it doesn’t matter anyway, for the dark, grimy photography and Halloween-like music firmly establishes Charles as a dangerous lunatic whose barely-concealed megalomania is fit to burst forth at any moment. This would seem to be the solitary point of the show: he’s no Stalin, he’s something else entirely – perhaps some strange and unfathomable being, existing outside of the space/time continuum altogether.

Alternatively, maybe his baffling eccentricity is just the result of centuries of controlled in-breeding. I’m only saying what Simon Barnes didn’t have the guts to.

Noel Brown

Categories
General TV stuff

The Sopranos

Does Tony Soprano get shot every week?

There’re only about ten dramatic plots available to writers, it is said. If that’s the case, the writers of The Sopranos must’ve exhausted their quota some time ago. The show’s back for a new series, and very welcome it is too, because it’s still good. In the first episode, Mafiosi and all-round family man, Tony Soprano, gets shot.

Now, I’m not a regular watcher of The Sopranos, but doesn’t he get shot at least once every season? And always makes a full recovery? This time he takes the wound in his stomach. I’m tempted to make some joke about the protective qualities of his vast gut, but really, it’s all been said before.

How about the show self-consciously acknowledges its limited repertoire, and Tony simply gets shot every episode? There would be no reference made to the previous week’s shooting at the start of the next one, of course. It could be a comforting, post-modern little recurring motif.

The shootings and all-round brutality notwithstanding, The Sopranos sometimes elicits a very peculiar feeling in me. There’s a very old-worldy comfort in the characters and their situations, which sounds strange until you take a look at the cast. It’s like some sort of reunion for old American Italian actors.

Frank Vincent, for example, the vaguely comedic mafia don from the Grand Theft Auto games, is there, and it’s slightly disconcerting to see him without the bald head and moustache of the games. Then there’s a whole dynasty of close-knit families.

It’s reminiscent of Moonstruck, the thoroughly charming Cher/Nicholas Cage romantic comedy which captures the Italian-American milieu in much the same way as The Sopranos, albeit with far less violent fervour. In fact, it’s easy to forget that this isn’t the world of Moonstruck.

Or is it…? You keep expecting Tony, halfway through inflicting a particularly unpleasant gangland mutilation upon an enemy, to suddenly drop to his knees and gaze longingly into the moon, in recognition of the supernatural, transformative powers therein.

On the other hand, Nicholas Cage could reprise his role as a partially-disabled romantic fool, but use his prosthetic hand as an aid to disembowelling rival gang members, in-between supplicating for the return of the values of the Age of Aquarius.

Perhaps there could be some kind of clearly-identified in-text trigger, signalling a sudden break from the violence of the show into the world of fairytale romance. On hearing the Cher song ‘I Believe’, for example, Tony might immediately break into a heart-warming, celebratory dance, signifying the tonal shift in which mafia drama and rom-com’s are finally reconciled.

It’s all so very postmodern and witty, you see. Perfect for British TV. I might give the BBC a call. In fact, don’t bother: Russell T Davies has already pitched it.

Noel Brown

Hush child stop addlepating me!

Sign up here for more of this frack

Powered by WordPress Popup