Categories
New Series

Caves and Twins – The Lodger

Gareth Roberts’ latest attempt to write a decent Doctor Who episode after several disappointments was a genuinely off-beat effort. So was this budget-saver a Midnight or a Fear her?

Caves

 

Matt Smith – Pulls off another great performance, despite characterisation that seemed a little off.

Corden Bleu – James Corden was fairly understated and sympathetic – a well-judged performance from a frequently-annoying character.

Silent Not Golden – Murray Gold seemed either on holiday or extremely understated. I never noticed any intrusive sub-Harry Potter tripe this week, which was nice.

Day-to-day Doctor – The Doctor struggling to come to terms with everyday living was amusing, if a little overstated

Twins

 

Diminished Doctor- Subverting the Doctor’s character in an everyday setting was generally well done, but a little overdone and tiresome in places.

The Power of RTD – The plot was secondary, so it seems churlish to complain about it, but fixing the spaceship via the power of love was rather twee. Reeked of bad Tennant-era Who.

Empty Pond – Amy got rather lost in the mix, both insofar as the plot left her alone in the TARDIS, but poor old Pond seemed returned to a generic companion-in-distress cipher.

Overall it was an enjoyable little episode, and it was good to see Gareth Roberts finally locating his mojo, after previous episodes that ranged from underwhelming to bloody awful.

• Caves and Twins? What are you dribbling on about?

Go here: Caves and Twins

Categories
New Series

Caves and Twins: Vincent and the Doctor

Richard Curtis’ kinda long-awaited Doctor Who episode features Tony Curran as VIncent Van Gogh, in the latest ‘You’re brilliant you are, absolutely brilliant!’ historical character ep.

So, was it totally Blackadder or s steaming pile of pretty much everything else Curtis has done?

Caves

 

Set-up – The monster in the painting’ thing was a nice set-up

Tony Curran – Pretty convincing, didn’t ham it up and generally hit the right notes

Location – Looked nice, and gave the episode a very different look to previous series

Central performances – Curtis made Smith look foolish on occasion, but the three lead characters all did well, and made the emotional pay-off work.

Couple of funny one-liners

Twins

 

Stupid Doctor – Curtis made the Eleventh Doctor into his posh idiot cypher, and Matt Smith suffered as a result. Did neither character nor actor any favours.

Another unconvincing CGI monster – Is that the third, or fourth, or fifth this season?

Plot – Admittedly not the really the point, but didn’t seem to make much sense.

Athlete – Fucking hell. Made Murray Gold look like Leonard Cohen.

All in all, something of a curate’s egg. A brave move to take the series into fairly unexplored territory, and generally carried off well. A dodgy plot, some iffy characterisation and treacley end didn’t detract from an emotionally-satisfying ep on the whole though.

• Caves and Twins? What are you dribbling on about?

Go here: Caves and Twins

Hush child stop addlepating me!

Sign up here for more of this frack

Powered by WordPress Popup