Categories
New Series

Change, my dear: Matt Smith and female Doctors

So, Matt Smith is off for a Hollywood career, leaving Doctor Who behind to attempt what no former Doctor has ever really achieved.

Oh sure, Tennant and Eccleston get the character actor bits from time-to-time, McGann flirted with the States in the 90s, but none of the modern Doctors has ever really managed it. On gross, I suspect Sylv is ahead, given his fairly meaty part in the new Hobbit films (on a sidenote it’s worth pointing out that Tom was asked to audition for Gandalf and Sylv for Bilbo in the original Peter Jackson trilogy – how squeetastic would that have been?).

I’m a little saddened. When Smith stopped twirling, waving his sonic around and being an idiot (seemingly a trope that all Timelords are required to adopt these days) he was a fine actor and a very good Doctor. His flair for comedy got a lovely runout in The Crimson Horror and Amy’s Choice; and he showed some serious acting chops in the likes of the Angels two-parter, Name of the Doctor, A Good Man Goes To War, The Doctor’s Wife and a couple of others.

What Smith really brought to the table, however, was a gaucheness, an awkwardness that was very Doctorish. These were Smith’s best moments; his Doctor’s defining charactiersitcs, which is why it was always such a shame to see writer after writer giving him Big Portentous Speeches or the nonsense with River Fucking Song when it was made clear again and again that The Eleventh Doctor just doesn’t get kissing and all that boring stuff. It reminds me a little of Iain Briggs claiming that Sylvester McCoy played anger very well, so he gave him lots of angry bits to do in Fenric. I’ve a lot of time for him as an actor, but anger is one of Sylv’s least convincing emotions, bless him.

Doctor-Who

By the time Tennant went he was well past his sell-by-date, as were Tom, Jon and arguably Billy and Pat. But I feel that we’re just getting to know Matt Smith as The Doctor. As a young man coming into the role, his appearance has actually changed quite a lot since his debut – and his characterisation shifts intriguingly once you get past the ‘zany Doctor’ stuff that everyone seems to think is a necessity in Doctor Who episodes these days.

Unlike Tennant, Smith is believably alien. You could believe he actually is very old, from another planet and genuinely sexless. The latter part reinvigorated an aspect of the character that had become depressingly predictable – snog a companion, feel lonely – and reconnected The Doctor with his previous incarnations. Oh there were aspects of it, but Smith actually played it like he disinterested, bemused and slightly disgusted by physicality.

Physicality. Has an actor ever brought such physical presence to the role? The Eleventh Doctor is twitchy, hunched and slightly tic-y. When he runs he looks a bit like a spider. His posture is terrible, but it all builds a picture of a rounded character, slightly awkward within his own body, which is kinda fitting when you think about it.

But Smith is off. Certainly at the height of his powers as far as his run is concerned, but I would have liked another season of him. Instead we’re now weighing up the likes of Rory Kinnear – a candidate who I will categorically rule out right now as some sort of Paterson Joseph-like flack – Domnhall Gleeson, Dominic Cooper, Olivia Colman and Idris Elba.

Most, if not all, have gone out of their way to deny that it’s them, which is exactly what they would say if it were one of them (Cooper even went so far as to voice his puzzlement with the programme and express the view that the lead character flew around the universe killing insects). I think it unlikely it will be a ‘name’, with most being the fancy of a bored reporter probably scanning Doctor Who forums in search for exclusives.

Rory-Kinnear-Doctor-Who

Once again, with dreary predictability, the prospect of a female Doctor has been filling either vacuous or pompous column inches. While this has been the case since JN-T’s day there are now boring articles from post-feminist writers about how the show has been insulting women since 1963 thanks to its patriarchal refusal to give the show a female Doctor. One supposed candidate, Helen Mirren, voiced the opinion that the new Doctor should be gay, black and a woman.

My view on this is simple. The Doctor is a man. Beyond some throwaway comments we have no indication that Time Lords (also bear in mind their female counterparts are called Time Ladies) swap gender. There have been at least eleven incarnations of The Doctor and not once has he been female. The same goes for half a dozen incarnations of The Master, several for Borusa and a couple for Omega and River Fucking Song (essentially a female Doctor and pretty fucking insufferable).

River-Song

I see no explanation for why there shouldn’t be a Doctor played by a man with different-coloured skin or by a a gay man. Within the Doctor Who universe it goes without saying that race is not an issue, not to the Doctor or his companions at least. Not would the sexual persuasion of an actor (presumably) impact on the character who is largely sexless.

But I don’t see any argument for giving the part to a female actor that amounts to much beyond ‘why not?’ and ‘because it’s teh sexist!’. In the former case I don’t see that this amounts to more than dreary gimmickry, a kind of listless fiddling with the core concept of the show. In the latter I find it astonishingly patronising that some people feel a female Doctor would right some historic wrong that has been perpetrated towards womankind.

Indeed, many female voices seem to have voiced much the same opinion: if a female Doctor is simply about some quasi-political statement of balance then it’s little more than an empty gesture, and an insulting one at that. The rejuvenated show has showcased strong, intelligent, resourceful and self-possessed women as companions, friends, possibly lovers, allies and enemies.

Something else that’s caught my eye is the roll-call of names perpetually regurgitated in terms of the female Doctor debate – and it does not convince me that the majority of its exponents have the slightest idea about Doctor Who. Why else would Miranda Hart and Sue Perkins – two of the most annoying people on television – be mentioned so frequently? I suspect that many who are wading into this debate are the kind of rent-a-controversial-opinion gobshites that newspapers love and the web thrives on.

sue perkins dr who

Putting one’s voice against the female Doctor idea is the equivalent of stepping into some geeky beartrap. It’s fairly easy to label – explicitly or insidiously – anyone who thinks the idea of a female Doctor is a crap idea as sexist, antediluvian or (the favourite implication of a certain kind of Doctor Who fan) as a sad virgin who’s afraid of women.

I see Paul Cornell has pretty much adopted all three – stating that any argument whatsoever against a female Doctor is, by necessity, ‘unreasonable and horrible’ – which comes as no surprise given his well-documented love of the fairer sex. Cornell then conflates the issue with gay marriage; the implication seems to be that if you don’t want the Doctor to regenerate into a woman you must be sexist and homophobic. Crikey.

This attitude infuriates me as it seems to be an excuse for a certain kind of fan to imply his sexual and intellectual capacity over others. The notion of some Doctor Who fans being cooler than others amuses me no end, but the sniffy superiority of this right-on fan (lest I detour into white poppies, white kids and the hoary old Pertwee-was-a-Tory drivel) is one of the least attractive elements in fandom, and I include DWB in that statement.

There are some arguments against a female Doctor that are not valid. Certainly there are many superb actresses out there, children would not be confused by the notion, I find the ‘no male role-model’ argument a bit bemusing (thought it has come most notably from women in my experience) and there probably is an element of fandom that harbours a certain amount of misogyny – there’s a particularly witless article on the subject on The Daily Mail – but the ‘female Doctor’ debate has simply provided a particular section of fandom to demonstrate how ‘cool and sex’ they believe themselves to be.

I don’t want to see it. Perhaps a woman would play the part in a way that would delight me, but I doubt the writers could make it work. Moffat’s female characters are much-discussed and somewhat problematic to my mind, while the navel-gazing wretchedness of Chibnall’s take on the subject makes me wince just thinking about it. The show is not currently firing on all cylinders and I don’t have a lot of trust in the production team – lobbing a dangerous gimmick such as changing the sex of The Doctor would likely kill off my fading enthusiasm for NuWho.

Setting aside all the wearying Guardianista wibbling about gender politics, ‘why not?’ seems to be as good as the pro argument gets. In a programme where anything is possible it frequently proves impossible for writers to resist pointless tweaking and meddling for the sheer Hell of it. Doctor Who is famously the programme in which anything can happen, but that doesn’t mean that anything should happen. The show has core strengths; certain solidities and realities. One of them, for me, is that The Doctor is a man, however horrible and unreasonable that makes me in some corners of the universe.

Categories
New Series

Caves and Twins – Series 7

So, that was the 50th anniversary season. Well, half of it anyway, or was it? Does season 7a count as the same season, really? And, if so, does this count as the 50th anniversary season?

I’m dancing around the fact that, for me, the split season thing is an absolute mess. The BBC seems less keen to invest in the show, in terms of in-channel advertising, scheduling and external promotion; less people seem keen on watching it, at least in my personal experience. And for all the time that Moffat buys the production team with the split seasons, you certainly couldn’t say that the quality has improved.

So where does this leave us? Doctor Who still seems reasonably healthy when timeshifts and the like are taken into account, but anecdotally the Beeb and my friends and acquaintances seem a lot less enamoured of Doctor Who than in recent years. Is Doctor Who still any good? And what exactly is going on with the production team?

In answer the latter, I seem reasonably confident that you can tease out the likely situation through cross-referencing a few different sources, applying a hefty dose of cynicism and adding a dash of common sense. For what it’s worth it’s my view that Moffat simply has too much on his plate to turn out episodes of the quality of his earlier stuff, but Sherlock brings certain personal financial imperatives that Doctor Who doesn’t, given that his mother and wife run Hartswood Films, which makes the updated Conan-Doyle drama. It’s a scenario straight out of one of Moffat’s own battle-of-the-sexes sitcoms and, in many ways, hardly an ideal one.

Furthermore, the fact that Doctor Who’s showrunner seems to shed producers like he does plot macguffins doesn’t add to an image of a programme in rude health. There are some rather more lurid suggestions, alluded to in Private Eye, as to why Caro Skinner left the show a few days after the most recent Doctor Who Magazine (soon to be brought back under BBC auspices if rumours are to be believed) published a glowing ‘best ever!’ column by the erstwhile exec.

If the rumours, commonly repeated from seemingly multiples sources, are to be believed the BBC wants more Doctor Who than Moffat is willing or able to produce, lessening the coporation’s faith in its flagship (?) show. But the Beeb is in a bind – Moff is in charge and doesn’t seem ready to give the keys; there are no obvious successors in the wings should there be a coup (surely Gatiss, Chibnall or Whithouse would decry such a situation and I suspect the Beeb would not trust a not-we with DW). The David Yates film rumour was, supposedly, an attempt to bounce Moffat into some sort of action, but the Scot simply brushed it off with an apparently-light ‘get your kids off my lawn’ statement that actually seemed very strident.

Hence split seasons that theoretically allow the misfiring production team more time and space to craft quality Doctor Who. If only. While I prefer to watch Who while it’s cold and dark outside, I can’t think of any other positives of the split series. It saps impetus, it means that story arcs are unbearably drawn-out affairs and, despite what Moffat says, the ongoing storylines are impossible to follow without repeat viewings. I don’t don’t have the slightest idea what Series Six was all about and I couldn’t really care less either.

So while the break in production should allow for more finely-honed tales, that really doesn’t seem to be the case. This season we’ve had perhaps the worst all-time duffer in The Rings of Akhaten, slated by such well-known haters as Radio Times and Doctor Who Magazine, and a pile of underwhelming episodes that include Nightmare in Silver, Cold War, The Power of Three, Dinosaurs on a Sodding Spaceship and A Town Called Mercy. Even the ‘big’ episodes – Asylum of the Daleks and The Angels Take Manhattan – were overplotted and unengaging, relatively speaking.

Secondly, is Doctor Who currently any good? It’s hard to say, objectively. The last two years of Moffat’s reign have seen a move to elaborate, tricksy and fairly incoherent storytelling that takes some of the excesses of Russell T Davies’ era and turns them up to 11. Stories are resetted continuously, notional rules are abandoned or ignored, stories or storylines appear to contradict one another and there’s very little that appears to make a huge amount of sense.

I personally find this mode of storytelling incredibly unsatisfying – and I suspect it’s born not of any intent, but necessity. It was frequently apparent that RTD wrote himself into corners and would end up simply making something up or pressing a big, fat reset switch. Moffat initially seemed to eschew these habits but he’s been far worse of late. Again and again in this series we’ve seen people die and come back to life; it’s as lazy as some of Moffat’s plotting and it becomes hard to care about characters who are not really subject to any threat.

Moffat has described his style on Who as compressed storytelling and suggested that all of season seven’s episodes are akin to a Hollywood blockbuster. I suspect this is an exercise in branding more than anything; suggesting that your breakneck, whizz-bang storytelling is some sort of new paradigm in television fiction does, after all, sound better than the more prosaic likelihood; block, lack of time and apathy. That last bit is perhaps a reach on my part, but I can attest to how the jobs you should love the most can quickly become just another job when the inexorable weight of deadlines and daily grind impinge on your life.

The unconvincing earnestness, the appeals to emotion, the complex plotting that doesn’t actually seem to stand up when observed, the seemingly-abandoned storylines (Silence Will Fall?), a Doctor veering closer to self-parody all the time, the apparent struggles with the anniversary appearances – they all suggest to me a man running of ideas, patience and love for the show, and a job he has surely coveted for most of his professional life. I honestly don’t understand how anyone could have commissioned The Rings of Akhaten, some of the worst television I’ve ever seen, unless something is going very wrong along the line.

And yet there are positive signs. Neil Cross’ other script, Hide, was excellent. Gatiss finally found his Doctor Who form with the wonderful, creepy, mischievous The Crimson Horror. And Moffat’s own scripts were much stronger than the underwhelming Silence arc of the previous season.

The Name of the Doctor was actually wonderful stuff, I thought, barring any of the bits that involved the execrable River Song, the worst Mary Sue in fiction and a character than never fails to make Doctor Who unbearable (barring, perhaps, The Time of Angels/Flesh and Blood). The vignettes of old Doctors, while shonky, were lovely to see and I fell in love with Jenna Louise Coleman over the course of the episode; I actually enjoyed the resolution to the story arc in the end. Strax is superb fun and there was more fanwanking than at a Doctor Who convention with John Nathan-Turner. But I think that’s OK now and then – if a 50-year-old show can’t get a bit self-indulgent now and then, what can? Plus that epic reveal, which I’d annoyingly spoiled for myself, was still epic.

So, Moffat still has it in him – the film-poster moments of the Daleks and Angels episodes and the wit and vim of the Christmas episode and finale prove it. But for how much longer? And how much is there in the tank? Moff himself has admitted that when something is over you know it instinctively. The questionable quality of Series 7 might suggest that Moff’s own Trenzalore is approaching. But he’s enough of a canny old campaigner that he knows to give viewers a hook to get them coming back. And what a hook this last episode gave us.

I’ve said this before, but I’ll be tuning in next time around with hopes high. With any luck they won’t be totally misplaced, but this is Moffat’s last chance to show that he’s genuinely up to the job – Season 7 strikes me as the being the first time the new series of DW has taken a significant wobble, following from an underwhelming Season Six. In the production break the team producing our series need to take a look at what works and what doesn’t, jettison some baggage and be honest about what isn’t working. If the quality doesn’t improve I genuinely believe that Who will move to an Only Fools And Horses-style format, with mini-series and specials taking the place of full series. Or, even worse, a Doctor Who movie.

For now I’m looking forward to an anniversary special and I’m personally glad Moffat is in charge. He’s a Doctor WHo fan first and foremost and I still have enough faith in him to pull it out of the fire – this is the man, after all, who wrote The Empty Child, Blink, The Girl In The Fireplace, The Eleventh Hour and The Time of Angels. For now we’ll just ignore The Beast Below, Let’s Kill Hitler, The Wedding of River Song, The Bells of Saint John…

Series Seven

Caves

Asylum of the Daleks
The Angels Take Manhattan
The Snowmen
Hide
The Crimson Horror
The Name of the Doctor

Twins

Dinosaurs on a Spaceship
A Town Called Mercy
The Power of Three
The Bells of Saint John
The Rings of Akhaten
Cold War
Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS
Nightmare in Silver

Hush child stop addlepating me!

Sign up here for more of this frack

Powered by WordPress Popup